Re: [syndication] Javscript links and NewsReaders

["Bill Kearney" <wkearney@syndic8.com>]

> > Why not instead link to a page which has an onLoad() Javascript handler
> > which does the right thing?
>
> That will run you into a problem with pop-up blockers.
>
> I'm not a big fan of forced pop-up windows - they remove control from
> the user. For instance, I'm denied the choice of opening the page in a
> new tab.
>
> Bill Kearney points out that Javascript in aggregators is frowned on.
> The platypus attack is an excellent demonstration of why.

Yes, I mean, let's get to the real question, what has it been decided that using
client-side scripting is the right way to implement this?  What goals are being
served by requiring use of scripting?  There are often very few reasons that
justify the use of scripting.  Fewer still that actually benefit the user.

> It also allows well-authored aggregators to cut out javascript and still
> leave a URL thats useful to the reader.

And all aggregators should be stripping out scripting.  Or, when possible,
integrating with the OS to determine security levels appropriate for scripting.
The latter is a quagmire of security risks so I'd caution against having it
actually work properly.

> Those people comfortable with running scripts in their aggregator will
> get your content as you intend it. Those people who prefer no scriping
> in their aggregator have that choice.

Again, if there's a sound reason for using scripting let's hear it.

-Bill Kearney
Syndic8.com